Wednesday, February 15, 2023

Book Review: "I Who Have Never Known Men" by Jacqueline Harpman


 
I Who Have Never Known Men is a relatively unheard of Belgian novel--first published in French in 1995--that made its way across the Atlantic in the late 2000s, most recently retranslated into English in May of 2022. Perhaps it is how recently it was released, but this book was surprisingly difficult to find. In addition the difficulty in finding it, the book itself is absolutely bizarre, reminding me of a fever dream. Like the written version of a Salvador Dali painting, Harpman depicts a desolate landscape, a world totally devoid of meaning or explanation. From a brief description, it may sound like a typical dystopian novel: thirty-nine women and a young girl--the narrator--are imprisoned in a cage in an underground bunker. They have enough food, water, and shelter, though they are deprived of many necessities they once knew. They are not allowed to die, touch each other, or defy the orders of the guards that constantly watch them. When an alarm goes off, the guards flee, and the women are let loose on a world very different from the one they expected. While many dystopias focus on bringing down an authoritarian government, the force that imprisoned the women is never seen, let alone confronted, which only adds to the unsettling tone of the book. The narrator--simply known as the Child--has no memory of the world before, never develops into a woman, and has no understanding of societal norms, leaving her with absolutely no context on what it means to be a woman--or human for that matter--in modern society. Without any sort of moral upbringing, ideas that would abhor us do not seem to phase her, and Harpman uses the child to examine and confront western values to a degree that at times gets incredibly disturbing. The Child’s lack of social context gives her an almost robotic view of the world and people around her. The characters are seldom fleshed out, but this choice seems deliberate. Each character plays a single critical role in the feverish thought experiment that Harpman creates, and we are only told the details needed for this to succeed. Harpman was born to a Jewish Family who fled to Morocco during World War II, and later worked as a psychoanalyst, all of which may have influenced her writing. It poses questions, and gets the gears turning, and I did enjoy the surreal world she creates. Yet I’m not sure how to recommend it, or even if I should. The book is at times very nihilistic and is at times incredibly upsetting and disturbing, and the Child’s treatment of certain issues is borderline-callous. I Who Have Never Known Men is at once awful, hauntingly beautiful, heartbreaking, depressing and at times downright distressing. It’s a rough ride, though it isn’t one I regret taking. I would, however, advise proceeding with caution.

________________________

Kramer Paper Online - Vol. LXXVII

Crawdads and Comets

Daisies grow on the shore of a surprisingly clear

 Timothy Lake in Summer, 2022. Mt. Hood can

 be seen over the ridge of trees across the lake.         

    It’s been said that you can never go home: your memory of a place will never be what you find when you return. The truth of these words rang especially true during the Covid Pandemic, as the whole world held its breath, and this mutual tension permeated every aspect of life. But to be “home” so to speak, everything need not be the same: so long as it remains familiar. My family treasures the outdoors, and with campgrounds still open, in July 2020 we decided to return to one of our favorite getaways: Timothy Lake, a large reservoir in the Cascades maintained by Portland General Electric as water storage for their hydro-electric projects. Its shores are lined by campgrounds, huckleberry bushes and gravel beaches for swimming. Massive stumps, ghosts of the forest that once stood in the lake bed, still stand under the surface, intact after nearly half a century. From the right angle, you can see stunning views of Mt. Hood. The Drive up 26 that summer was no less magical, climbing out of the canyon carved by Camp Creek, towards the summit. Mt. Hood slid in and out of view as the road curves around hills, becoming larger and larger each time. 

    That July afternoon, the lake appeared the same, but things definitely felt different. Signs warned people not to gather too close, and advised masks. The sense of concealed hysteria

was fainter here, but not fully extinguished. Timothy Lake, while somewhat remote, is close enough to Portland to have cell service, and with it, news updates, and the emotional whiplash from conflicting reports sharing both optimism and pessimism about the situation. Yet there is a certain peace in a place like Timothy Lake, regardless of what’s going on outside. Families still gathered on the lakeshore and chatted amongst themselves. Boats meandered across the sparkling water and children swam in the various lagoons and bays. As dusk fell, a ukulele began to play, smoke from cooking fires filled the air, and children returned to the lake to stalk crawdads.

    I took note of this last bit, and on the second night I grabbed a flashlight and went down to try my own luck. Sure enough, there were dozens of crawdads, using the cover of night to evade predators and hunt prey of their own. I wandered down the lake shore almost as far as the dam, only stopping when I came to a family gathered around a campfire. As I approached, someone got up from the fire and began wandering my way: perhaps I had gotten a bit too close. I turned around and headed back along the beach trail towards camp. After a minute or so, I looked back, assuming that the pursuer had turned around, but the flashlight was still following me. I decided to quit running. If this guy needed to talk to me, so be it. 

Comet Neowise, seen from the suburbs of
Portland, Summer, 2020
    I greeted my supposed pursuer, with a “Good evening.” He replied in kind, then added “Hey, did you see the comet?” I looked where he was pointing. Amid the stars was a faint dusty object. During the day I would have thought it to be a distant contrail, but it was night, and the object wasn’t moving. My heart leapt. I thanked him and like a child, sprinted all the way back to camp, where I breathlessly stormed the trailer--waking my family in the process--and said something about a comet. They were none too happy to be disturbed, but they went back with me, and together we took in this rare sight. They were glad to see it, and even after they returned to camp, I stayed by the lake, and watched it set behind the hills. When I returned home, I made two trips into the countryside where the sky was darker to photograph the comet: once alone, and once with a friend.

    A couple of years have gone by, and things have changed, some for better and some for worse. This year we returned to the lake. There were fewer people--though it was later this time, and the place still wasn’t lonely. Children were still playing in the lagoons, and boats still slide across the sparkling waves. Each return trip feels different, but at the same time it feels familiar. The night sky was as beautiful as ever, though there was no comet. It has long since turned around and headed back from whence it came, going about its existence. Some day, it will return. The world it sees then will be different, but some things will no doubt still be the same. 

____________________________

Kramer Paper Online - Vol. LXXVII

45º06'50"N 121º48'00"W

Monday, February 17, 2020

Swift Watching at Chapman School


Enter the Swifts

 Living here for over twenty years now, I can attest that I live in a very unique city. I admit, there are many things about this city that are downright weird, or even slightly off-putting. That being said, other things that make Portland stand out are not peculiar at all, just unique: experiences that are rarely seen elsewhere. Case in point, the Voux's Swifts of Chapman School.
At dusk, the swifts begin to
descend into the chimney
 en mass, forming a living
 funnel-like cloud.
Voux's swifts are a migratory bird, similar to swallows. While in the forest, they nest in hollowed out dead trees, but any hollow object will do. And as Portland expanded in their migration pattern, they seemed to take a fondness to the chimney of an elementary school in Northwest Portland. The school went out of its way to accommodate the birds, even going so far as to leave the furnace off  until the birds left again. 
 When the furnace was converted to gas, the chimney was retained and is now used exclusively for this purpose. When you arrive for the swift watching, you can see their efforts: plates and cables of steel acting as guy-wires to prevent the chimney from collapsing.

The show begins...

Swift watching at Chapman School is a multi-facetted tradition. It is a community picnic, birdwatching, and a theatre performance somehow rolled into one. It’s unlike normal bird watching in a number of ways. It's not solitary, or quiet. No one needs to remain still lest they scare the birds, and while they help, binoculars aren't needed. Come to think of it, it's little different from an evening at the theatre. Not a show to see human's act out a well written fictional storyline, but a real story, unfolding before everyone's eyes. It's a live nature documentary, and a spectacle that is rarely seen outside of the deep old growth forests of British Columbia, far from anyone who could record the experience.
Upon arriving, the show hasn't begun yet. Swifts dart around overhead, like an orchestra warming up prior to a concert. The Audubon society has a booth set up with an exhibit depicting swifts and bats (for size comparison) as well as information about the birds, and a deeper ornithological explanation of the evening's events for those who are interested. A scope is set up aimed at the chimney where the swifts will spend the night, and people periodically approach it to get a quick look at the birds that have begun fluttering around the chimney. Some people bring lawn chairs, others sit on blankets. Many bring their dinner to eat, and those with children bring slabs of cardboard which become makeshift sleds to slide down the bare grass slopes.

Heroes and Villains...

The Audubon Society has a scope
on site to view the birds. Viewing
through the scope gets one up close
and personal with these birds.
As the sky darkens the birds sense this, and begin diving for the chimney. Small flocks approach the chimney in a swooping motion. A handful will go in, while the remainder circle around again to let those in front of them get settled. On some evenings, a hawk will fly into the school yard, seeing these small birds as a quick evening snack. People truly want to see the swifts succeed, and as a spectator, you get invested in the experience.  As if watching a drama in the outdoor theaters of old, the attendees boo the hawk as it arrives, and gasp in awe and horror as it goes in for the kill. The swifts become the heroes in this tale of survival that no doubt repeats itself day in and day out as the swifts migrate south to Mexico. The difference being that here, this daily battle is on display for hundreds of curious Portlanders. There was no hawk this evening, but the show itself never disappoints.
As the sky gets darker and darker, the birds spiral into the chimney, like seeds being poured down a funnel. Rarely do we stay until the last one is in, but by this point, it's too dark to see. As the birds huddle up inside the chimney for the night, the spectators do as well, heading for their cars with the blankets, chairs and children they brought along. But like the swifts, many will return year after year, to witness this beautiful spectacle, boo the hawk, and cheer the tiny aerobats as they travel south as their ancestors have done for generations. -KP

More photos of the Swan Island Dahlia Festival

Hello everyone! It was difficult for me to choose just three photos that best illustrated the article about the dahlia fields so...here are ...